Review: As Many Souls As Stars, by Natasha Siegel

1592. Cybil Harding is a First Daughter. Cursed to bring disaster to those around her, she is trapped in a house with a mother paralyzed by grief and a father willing to sacrifice everything in pursuit of magic. Miriam Richter is a creature of shadow. Forged by the dark arts many years ago, she is doomed to exist for eternity and destined to be alone—killing mortals and consuming their souls for sustenance. Everything changes when she meets Cybil, whose soul shines with a light so bright, she must claim it for herself. She offers a bargain: she will grant Cybil reincarnation in exchange for her soul. Thus begins a dance across centuries as Miriam seeks Cybil in every lifetime to claim her prize. Cybil isn’t inclined to play by the rules, but when it becomes clear that Miriam holds the key to breaking her family curse, Cybil finds that—for the first time in her many lives—she might have the upper hand. As they circle each other, drawn together inescapably as light and dark, the bond forged between them grows stronger. In their battle for dominance, only one of them can win—but perhaps they can’t survive without each other.

"So come once again and love me." 

Natasha Siegel's As Many Souls as Stars is a stunning tale of cat and mouse, a sapphic Faustian bargain that spans centuries and three lives as reincarnation makes the chase last longer and cut deeper. Profoundly vicious and filled with hate-driven longing, this gorgeous novel pulls no punches as it asks, perhaps, what it means to be human.

The atmospheric writing lulls the reader as it depicts the many trials of women's lives in the Sixteenth and Eighteenth Century and the more supernatural threat of an obsessed being that thrives on deals. Miriam is a passionate, dangerous antagonist and love interest, her smile a sharp knife and her love perfectly toxic. Cybil handles herself well against such a foe, her intellect razor sharp and her planning careful. Theirs is a dance that can have no other ending, working perfectly.

The novel falls maybe a little short in the pacing, spending little time establishing Cybil's reincarnations, and casting unanswered questions over the workings of the process in the third act. But the gorgeously gothic atmosphere makes up for these stumbles, creating a perfectly contained novel.

As Many Souls as Stars is a lush treat.

✨ 4 stars